SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL RESEARCH COMMITTEE ON SAFETY AND HEALTH IN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES
Western medicine and the Chinese vision
Papers and debates, 18 November 1999
1st part : Western medicine  
Summary
 
 
DEBATE

 

Mr AMOUDRU thanked the chairman for taking the initiative of this symposium. He stated that the statistics on pneumoconioses in France are mainly based on risk management (pensions created, entitlement to survivors' pensions, etc.); he observed the scarcity of detailed epidemiologic data (except for a few studies on collieries). This shortage is particularly detrimental as regards the development of new or revised tables on occupational diseases.

He recalled the longevity of the biopersistence of silica particles in the pulmonary parenchyma. In effect these particles keep their cytopathogenic power even when the subject is no longer exposed, which forms a specific difficulty as regards the preventive or therapeutic actions envisaged.

Mr COCUDE, speaking to Dr PUJET, wished to know the proportion of men and women concerned by respiratory rehabilitation and if différent behaviours appear.

Mr PUJET: The proportion of men is higher concerning occupational and tobacco-caused diseases but women are beginning to catch them up regarding tobacco. Readaptation motivation is limited, firstly because of the low number of centres and doctors experienced in the therapy, and, secondly because some patients are both tobacco and alcohol addicts and must previously lose their addiction.

Regarding the therapy programme, women are seen to be stricter than men, but all progress normally when motivated. As for pneumoconiotics, rehabilitation proves the best therapy compared with drugs or oxygen, with an iraprovement of, for instance, fifty per cent of the distance covered in a six minute walk.

Mrs MINGAM: When Dr PUJET describes the respiratory rehabilitation of pneumoconiotics and the eloquent results he obtains, that makes me think exactly about the readaptation of chronic patients in pain: currently, in France, several functional reeducation centres or services propose effort re-training or physical reactivation programmes for chronic lumbago sufférers allowing thern to rediscover an acceptable quality of life despite their paînful handicap.

1 am pleased to see that for two différent types of pathologies the therapeutic approach. to be adopted follows the same guideline.

Mr COCUDE asked Dr MARQUET to draw the conclusions of this first part regarding miners sufféring from pneumoconiosis.


Top of page
Next talk
Summary