SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL RESEARCH COMMITTEE ON SAFETY AND HEALTH IN EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES
Western medicine and the Chinese vision
Papers and debates, 18 November 1999
1st part : Western medicine  
Summary

 
1945 - 2000
HALF A CENTURY OF DIAGNOSTIC AND THERAPEUTIC PROGRESS

M. MARQUET

. .

MEANS OF DIAGNOSING PNEUMOCONIOSES AND TREIR COMPLICATIONS

A - Medical imagery

Radioscopy:

Used until the 1970s.

Advantages :
  • Allows respiratory kinetics to be visualised.
Disadvantages:

.

No filing of images, therefore no possibility of making a precise assessment of evolutionary potential;

  • Lack of precision of the images;
  • A single examiner: short examination time;
  • - High radiation of the patient and doctor.

.

Radiophotography.

Adapted to mass screening; Mobile equipment; large output; small size images easily filed; rapid interpretation. Evolution of films

  • At the beginning: flexible 35 mm format;
  • Progressively appearance of 7x7 cm then 10x10 cm and 11lx11 cm formats;

.

Advantages:

  • Possibility of double interpretation;
  • Improvement of image definition with an increase of the film surface
  • Lesser radiation of the patient.

.

Disadvantages:

  • Insufficient definition for fine images;
  • Documents not accepted in expertise procedures;
  • No reference image.

.

Standard radiography.-

35x35 mm image.

  • Made on paper film at the beginning (1945 / 1950), then use of transparent negative films;
  • Evolution of emulsions that have become ever finer and more sensitive (shorter exposure times)
  • Evolution of cassettes, of intensifying screens, and of grids;
  • Switch froin low voltage images (60 kV) to high voltage images (110 kv) allowing the rib cage to be effaced in order better to show the pulmonary parenchyma;
  • ILO refèrence images.
Digitised images:
  • Provide constant quality (penetration, contrasts);
  • Image definition depends on the quality of the matrix (number of pixels);
  • Definition lower than that of the silver grain;
  • Ease of filing without any risk of spoiling documents;
  • Possibility of processing images and absence of reference images.
Tomographies:
  • Used until the beginning of the 1990s;
  • Allow puknonary exploration by a slicing in successive vertical planes, eliminating images built by superposing the various pulmonary structures.
The scanner:
  • Has progressively replaced tomographies;
  • Pulmonary exploration by horizontal sections froin 1 mm to 1 cm thick;
  • Quality has considerably iniproved in the past five years (higher performance matrices);
  • Shorter acquisition time (spiral scanners);
  • Possibility of processing images (e.g.: summation of contiguous millimetre sections in order to assess a micronodular opacity);
  • High sensitivity in diagnosing interstitial images and emphysematous lesions barely visible in standard radiography and invisible in tomographic sections;
  • High sensitivity in diagnosing pleural images (pleural plaques in asbestosis).
Echography:
  • Uses the ultrasounds technique;
  • Developed from the 1980s on;
  • Interest in exploring the cardiac cavities (3D echo - Doppler echo).
AMR:
  • Uses the magnetic fields technique;
  • Supplies images of customarily radiotransparent soft tissues;
  • Acquisition time currently too long, which does not allow its use in pulmonary exploration.

 

B - Histology

.

Interest in tables 30 bis': 30 A,C,D;
Allows a defmitive diagnosis;
Accepted as diagnostic proof in table 25'.

Sampling methods:
  • Anatomic parts (surgery, autopsies);
  • Transbronchial biopsies during fibroscopies;
  • Transthoracic biopsies guided by scanner or brightness amplifiers;
  • Biopsies by pleuroscopies (mesotheliomas);
  • Bronchoalveolar lavages.

 

Endoscopy progress (from rigid endoscopy to fibroscopy)

.

C - Serodiagnosties
  • Immunoelectrophoresis used in diagnosing aspergillosis;
  • Markers of cancer development;
  • Search methods (sensitive crystallisation - search for markers of development potential).

.

D - Bacteriological diagnosis
  • Mainly in the carly diagnosis of tuberculosis.

.

THERAPEUTIC MANAGEMENT

A - Reminder on tests on stabilising the development of silicosis

cf above: Present research and prospects

B - Management of respiratory insufficîency and its complications

Treatment of chronic respiratory insufficiency

  • Progress in treating infections;
  • Progress in reanimation techniques;
  • Progress in material means allowing patients to be kept at home (mobility of heavy equipment such as assisted ventilation, oxygenotherapy);
  • Progress in medical monitoring (blood gases. - respiratory kinesitherapy).

(1) French decree no. 96-446 of 22 May 1996 on accupational diseases. The. table 30bis corxx-m branchopulmonary cancer caused by asbestosis.
(2) Occupational diseases caused by silica dust.

.

Treatment of tuberculosis

  • A major complication in 1945;
  • Vaccinations;
  • Earlier diagnosis;
  • Treated effectively in general, without after-effects nowadays;
  • - (Statistical results)-

 

Treatment of chronicpulmonary heart

  • Currently the most serious complication;
  • Use of long-term oxygenotherapy protocols.

 

Treatment of other complications (pneumothorax-aspergillomas, aseptic necroses, etc...)

.

C - Therapeutie management of MP 3W (Asbestosis)

Treatment of pulmonary fibrosis (30 A)

Treatment of bronchial cancers (30 C 30 bis)

  • Place of surgery;
  • Cherniotherapy,
  • Notion of associated cancer cofactors:
  • Non professional (tobacco)
  • Professional (wood dust +asbestos in moulding powders).

 

Treatment of mesothetiomas

Essential dedramatisationfor table 30 B

.

FUTURE PROSPECTS

  • Above all, prevention of exposure;
  • Early removal from the risk on the first signs of occupational diseases (MP 25);
  • More effective cancer treatment.

It should however be remembered that a destroyed lung does not regenerate and that all you can do is make best use of what remains.

 

.

(3) MP 30: Occupational Disease no. 30 in France (asbestosis), (Commission des maladies professionnelles du. Conseil supérieur de la prévention des risques profèssionnels)

.

9

.

To annexes :


Top of page
Next talk
Summary